Baseball superstars fail at image repair following steroid use

Fri, 02/28/2014

Contact

KU News Service
785-864-8860

LAWRENCE — The arrival of spring training and a new baseball season always brings hope for fans, but in the last decade it has brought talk of steroids, suspensions and apologies from superstars for using banned substances. A University of Kansas professor and master’s student have published a study examining the efforts of three of baseball’s biggest stars who attempted to repair their images after accusations of steroid use.

Max Utsler, associate professor of journalism, and Susie Epp, a former journalism master’s student, published a study in the Journal of Sports Media analyzing the televised image repair strategies of Mark McGwire, Alex Rodriguez and Barry Bonds. They examined the efforts through the lens of image restoration discourse theory. While they used varying tactics, the athletes had essentially the same results.

“Baseball had three prominent figures who tried to repair their images, and all three failed miserably,” Utsler said. “I’m amazed that more athletes don’t have enough of a sense of history to realize there are some good techniques to use in image repair and some that aren’t.”

Alex Rodriguez, currently on suspension for his role in a performance-enhancing drug scandal, was accused of steroid use several years before his current troubles. Utsler and Epp analyzed a 2009 interview he did with ESPN’s Peter Gammons in which he attempted to repair his image. He used three primary strategies: bolstering, mortification and blame shifting. He briefly used defeasibility in attacking his accuser.

In an athlete’s case, bolstering essentially attempts to remind people of their positive attributes while not explicitly denying accusations. Rodriguez reminded Gammons of his natural talent before moving on to the use of mortification, or admitting wrongdoing and asking for forgiveness. However, in Rodriguez’s case he claimed he was young and naïve when he took steroids, indicating he wasn’t truly accepting responsibility for his actions, Utsler said. Later in his interview he accused Sports Illustrated reporters of invading his privacy and attempting to sully his name by embellishing reports of his performance enhancing drug use.

Mark McGwire attempted his image repair in an interview with Bob Costas on the MLB Network. Utsler and Epp point out that he also used the primary strategies of bolstering, mortification and blame shifting. He frequently reminded Costas of his natural talent and great baseball mind, discussing the many home runs he hit from Little League through college and repeatedly referred to “the man upstairs” for giving him the talent to hit home runs. He admitted to use of steroids but insisted he was using them to recover from injuries and that they didn’t improve his strength or baseball ability, a dubious claim at best, Utsler said.

Barry Bonds was a unique case in that he fervently denied any steroid use and repeatedly attacked his accusers, belittling media members and claiming they were inventing stories of his steroid use without factual basis. He denied use in press conferences and even before a federal grand jury. When asked if he felt a need to apologize, Bonds apologized for having to answer such questions repeatedly.

Utsler said Bonds' continued use of denial is the least likely of the three players’ strategies to work or even be believable. Where children often learn that denial of wrongdoing at a young age will only lead to more trouble, that rarely seems to be the case with athletes such as Bonds.

“We’ve seen that lesson repeated so many times in so many ways,” Utsler said. “It’s a lesson that keeps being repeated but continues to be ignored. The media keep teaching it, yet superstars continue to ignore it.”

While Bonds, Rodriguez and McGwire’s initial attempts at image repair all failed, they have taken various paths since in getting back in the good graces of baseball fans and the establishment.

McGwire has been somewhat accepted again as a hitting coach, first for the St. Louis Cardinals and now for the Los Angeles Dodgers. Bonds retired in 2007 after a knee injury, continuing to deny any wrongdoing while retreating from the public spotlight. Rodriguez continued to play for the New York Yankees and was later dealt a lengthy suspension, leading him to sue Major League Baseball. He recently dropped the suit and is serving the suspension.

The lesson the three athletes offer for both fellow competitors and communications studies scholars is that denial and blame-shifting almost never work in the field of apologia. Ryan Braun of the Milwaukee Brewers provided a recent example of eventually learning that lesson. When originally charged with performance-enhancing drug use, he vehemently denied any wrongdoing, blaming testing officials. He eventually accepted his fate and took part in apologies to fans and the game, led by his team, while serving a suspension and getting back in the good graces of baseball.

Utsler and Epp argue that contributing to a winning team makes it much easier for athletes to gain forgiveness. However, that might not even be enough in the case of Rodriguez, who continues in his image repair saga.

“I think as more time passes A-Rod will go down as his own case study,” Utsler said. “Partly because of wearing the Yankee uniform and being in the New York media spotlight. He had the most to gain, and he also had the most to lose.”



KU in the news
Christian Science MonitorThu, 08/21/2014
Columbia Journalism ReviewThu, 08/21/2014
Did you know the Spooner-Thayer Art Museum was KU’s first art museum? It opened more than 50 years before the Spencer Museum of Art that we know today. Learn more here: http://bit.ly/1oKmgXn Tags: Spencer Museum of Art #KUtbt #TBT #KUdiscoveries #Art #Museum #Gallery #VisualArt Photo credit: University Archives in Spencer Research Library.

#KUstudents : It's time for Rock-A-Hawk! Come out to the Ellsworth/McCollum parking lot. #HawkWeek #ROCKchalk
Poet offers insights to Jayhawk experience through wordplay "Welcome to KU. Where questions rest, in stacks of answers from the past. …" Listen to Topher Enneking, a spoken word poet and former KU football player, as he weaves the experience of KU and its traditions through this storytelling and wordplay performance. Learn more about KU traditions at http://www.ku.edu/about/traditions/. Welcome to KU. Where questions rest in stacks of answers from the past. Where dreams crawl out of bed And learn to walk Uphill both ways. Where freshmen stand on stilts And hang from the rafters, While the wheat waves In a fieldhouse Where the Phog rolls in Helping us to see Through the past into the future. Haunting hosts giving handouts in a heritage Too heavy to grasp til you add to it. So it may be born anew, Allowing our boots to stand in the ash of oppression’s hate But shine bright as the sun While war cries of warriors past Ring in our ears long after their battles are won. Memorials telling time, “you don’t have to stand still.” Because the top of the world Is just up that Hill. Where our natural history is an awe-struck echo Of world’s fair and equal Past, present and future, prelude and sequel. Where our flags fly above planes. Where we build in chalks that can’t be erased. Stone edifices made to last So you would walk Past their doors, down their halls And let your voice fill their room. Because only in empty silence can destruction loom. So stand tall. Wrap your arms around this crowd Sing our alma mater and sing it out loud. Let your voice sing in chorus and reach other nations Beckoning new Jayhawks to spark new collaborations Because you are the mortar that will hold these walls upright. Your future Your dreams are why Jayhawks did fight For the tradition before you Was merely prelude For what will come next now that you’re at KU.


One of 34 U.S. public institutions in the prestigious Association of American Universities
26 prestigious Rhodes Scholars — more than all other Kansas colleges combined
Nearly $290 million in financial aid annually
1 of 9 public universities with outstanding study abroad programs.
—U.S. News & World Report
46 nationally ranked graduate programs.
—U.S. News & World Report
Top 50 nationwide for size of library collection.
—ALA
$260.5 million in externally funded research expenditures
23rd nationwide for service to veterans —"Best for Vets," Military Times